As I was cleaning up my new apartment, I listened to an episode of the Unbelievable podcast hosted by Justin Brierley. In this one, he mediated a conversation between Sean McDowell (son of famed apologist Josh McDowell) and a guy named Jon Steingard, who was the lead singer/guitarist for a Christian rock band named Hawk Nelson and had recently renounced his faith on Instagram. Steingard joins other semi-famous Christians over the last year or so to publicly apostasize such as Marty Sampson and Joshua Harris.
I honestly had never heard of Steingard or Hawk Nelson before (sorry, I’m not well-versed in the Christian music world), but I found his story interesting. I appreciated his openness and politeness, and it made for the kind of good conversation that seems so rare these days. There is much that could be discussed related to his story, but what I want to focus on is an interesting byproduct of his Christian rock star lifestyle: Once he started touring with the band, he didn’t really have a church for about a decade, often having to perform on Sundays and bouncing around from church to church based on wherever he happened to be. It certainly sounded like it wasn’t very conducive to his spiritual growth and the addressing of his doubts, and he even admitted that he felt scared to talk openly about his doubts because his livelihood depended on his status as a Christian rock star.
There’s a lot of teaching about how church community is important for growth, accountability, intimacy, emotional and financial support, and so forth. And all of those things are true and good. There may need to be more emphasis on this too: Community can serve as a place where doubts and questions are addressed and people’s faiths are ultimately strengthened. It should be an environment where theology and learning are done with others. I’m not interested here in debating whether or not someone can actually lose their faith; regardless of what your position on that is, I think we need to be reminded that community should be a place where honest doubts, both intellectual and emotional, can be expressed and ultimately dealt with in a loving manner.
Continue reading